Advanced search
Visit
6040
Last Updated: 2014/11/06
Summary of question
Why didn’t the prophets and imams leave any works behind as inventors and scientists did so that they could be prouder? Do Shiites have scholarly or scientific achievements to be proud of ?
question
A: Why didn’t the prophets and imams leave any works behind as inventors and scientists did so that they could be prouder? B: Why don’t Shiites have any scholarly achievements or any superiority over other religions which have made tremendous progress? Is it because of some misinformation?
Concise answer
Religion is not bound to create material means for man’s life. This is a duty of human beings themselves to use their mind and faculty of reason to create such things. Basically, it is wrong to expect the religion to create such means or tools to be used by people to live comfortable lives. Therefore, we cannot expect the prophets and imams to create and invent what has been created and made available by inventors and scientists.
However, when it comes to the accomplishments and achievements made by Muslims, it must be said that Muslims formed a civilization in which great scholars contributed to different branches of sciences such as philosophy theology, astrology, mathematics, poetry etc.  Shiites’ role therein has also been very profound and significant. In philosophy, we can name scholars like Bu Ali Sina (Avicenna) and Farabi who were Shiites. These two scholars had profound impacts on the philosophical thinking in the West so much so that Avicenna’s books used to be taught until the seventeenth century in Western universities.  In astrology also, Muslim scholars in general and Shiite scholars in particular, introduced many a number of theories. As well, Muslims laid the groundwork for many great and highly important methods for utilizing the human intellect in defense of the religion which is called ‘theology’.
Also, Islam, especially Shi’ism is among very few religions that stress profusely on using and benefiting from the intellect. It has encouraged its followers a lot to learn and acquire various sciences.  There are many instructions in Muslims’ religious texts in general and Shiite sources in particular encouraging Muslims to acquire knowledge of diverse sciences.
 
Detailed Answer
A) Religion is not bound to create material means for human life. This is a duty of the human beings themselves to use their minds and faculty of reason to create such things. Basically, it is out of place to expect the religion to create such means or tools to be used by people to live comfortable lives because the religion is not responsible to undertake manufacturing things such as electricity, cars, machines, etc. rather, religion has a major role to play in living a proper and correct spiritual life so that human beings may be able to achieve permanent salvation and success.
This discussion has something to do with “man’s expectations from religion” which is necessary to be explained with some details.[1] Man’s common expectation from the religion is to achieve eternal bliss through the ways designated and shown to us by Allah, the Exalted. Thus, the essentials to achieve this objective must be provided by the religion itself.  However, the material means which are very crucial to man’s life in this world and without which his life would be paralyzed, are meant for this material world and there is no need for them to achieve eternal bliss and felicity.
It is worth mentioning that fame and reputation does not give any credit to the thing or person who is famous. For example, if a sportsman is more famous among people than a scholar, you cannot claim that he is more valuable too because people, nowadays, give more importance to things which are less important and less worthy than those which are unknown. Now, if a globally known inventor, has served humanity through his invention and has achieved worldwide reputation, that is not a sign of him being more credible and more respectable than prophets and righteous people. In short, reputation is not something with which someone’s value and credibility may be measured.
B) Today, researches have been conducted about Shiites achievements and their impacts in various scientific arenas which we will touch on here briefly.
Most of Muslims’ achievements date back to the time when they built up a civilization which survived for several centuries.  Islam was the only religion which could lay the foundation of a great and profound civilization which greatly contributed to production of sciences and creation of skills and even served as a prelude to subsequent civilizations. Muslims formed a civilization in which great scholars contributed to different branches of sciences such as philosophy theology, astrology, mathematics, poetry etc.  Shiites’ role therein has also been very profound and significant. In philosophy, we can name scholars like Bu Ali Sina (Avicenna) and Farabi who were Shiites. These two scholars had profound impacts on the philosophical thinking in the West so much so that Avicenna’s books used to be taught until the seventeenth century in Western universities.  In astrology also, Muslim scholars in general and Shiite scholars in particular, introduced many a number of theories. As well, Muslims laid the foundation of many great and highly important methods for utilizing the human intellect in defense of the religion which is called ‘theology’.  Theological groups which included both Mu’atazilites and Shiites left a profound influence on the scholars of other religions.[2]
Finally, no mundane science depends entirely on a specific religion and such scientists and scholars emerged from various religions. No religion proves itself by way of the scholars subscribing to that religion or through their inventions. Nonetheless, Muslim scholars in general and Shiite scholars in particular had an undeniable role in the formation of modern sciences.[3] It goes without saying that this scientific competence and the influences of Muslim scholars of the then time on the followers of other faiths have been treated with unkindness and have very little been the subject of attention. There are some researchers who only in the last few years have embarked on conducting research into these subjects.
Finally, it should be said that Islam, especially Shi’ism is among very few religions that stresses profusely on using and benefiting from the intellect. It has encouraged its followers a lot to learn and acquire various sciences. In Shi’ism, the knowledgeable people enjoy a very high status and it shows that Islam and Shi’ism have what a religion needs to promote knowledge. Today, if very little is done, it is largely because of Muslims and Shiites, not Islam and Shi’ism.
 

[1]  For further information in this regard, vide: Ahmadi, Muhammad Amin, “Man’s Expectations from Religion”, Islamic Culture and Sciences Research Institute, Qom, 1384 (2005).
[2] For further information in this regard, vide: Rezapour, Muhammad Mahdi, Mu’atazilah’s Intellectual Influence on Jewish Theologians in the Tenth Century, MA Thesis, The University of Religions and Denominations, Qom, 1390.
[3] [3]  For further information in this regard, vide: Vilayati, Ali Akbar, The Role of Shia in Iran’s and Islam’s Culture and Civilization, Amir Kabir Publications, Tehran, 1389 (2010).
Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Is lobster, clam, oyster and octopus halal?
    110783 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/02/18
    Eating lobster, clam, oyster and octopus is haram. According to religious resources regarding halal and haram meat, there are general rulings and numerous standards; for instance, a set of rulings has been given for land animals, sea creatures, birds and so on.The condition for halal meat sea ...
  • Is ‘Apprehension’ a quality that can be attributed to God?
    6722 Traditional 2012/04/17
    Taking into consideration the verse “لا تُدْرِكُهُ الْأَبْصارُ وَ هُوَ يُدْرِكُ الْأَبْصارَ وَ هُوَ اللَّطيفُ الْخَبيرُ”[1], Mudrik (being apprehensive) is one of God’s names.[2] In the Quran and traditions, this attribute (Mudrik)[3] has been mentioned explicitly, thus ...
  • Please explain the concept of infallibility. Is it possible for anyone besides the infallible imams (as) to be infallible?
    11727 Traditional 2009/06/22
    In a theological dictionary, one the possesses infallibility would be defined as an infallible. An infallible is one who, by the grace of God, is free from all forms of mistake and error, and does not commit even the smallest of sins. However, one who is infallible isn't ...
  • What are the ways through which one may get rid of lusts?
    8337 Practical 2011/08/04
    Sins are like an ill-smelling putrid bog. The deeper a person gets into it the less he feels its disgusting smell because his smelling taste ceases to function. However, a person's firm decision to discontinue this path is by itself a victory. One who has achieved victory ...
  • How do we return to nothingness?
    8112 Contextual study 2009/09/23
    This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer. ...
  • What is meant by the Makr of Allah that has been mentioned in the Quran?
    22017 Exegesis 2011/04/20
    “Makr” means to devise for good or evil and this is why it is described by the word “السَّیئ” (bad/evil) in the Quran.Allah’s Makr: The many verses that attribute “Makr” to Allah refer to his supreme direction and regulation of matters.  Since he is the ...
  • Is it permissible to open and close tap several times during Wudhu so as not to waste water?
    8929 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/09/22
    Office of Grand Ayatollah Khamenei (may Allah grant him long life): There is no problem in it. Generally speaking, there is no objection in opening and closing tap before washing the left hand completely. However, if one touches a wet thing (such as a wet ...
  • What is Nafaqah?
    13509 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/04/19
    ‘Nafaqah’ is a jurisprudential term used for women, kin (relatives) and property. It is predominantly used for women/wives and denotes the financial support that is obligatory upon men (when certain conditions are met) to provide for their spouses.[1] The Nafaqah usually covers the wife’s ...
  • Are there any guidelines in the Islamic sources about fashion and clothing?
    9366 Practical 2012/07/15
    Although Islam lays great emphasis on spiritual modesty of human beings (clothing of piety), the outward clothing is also a bounty which God, the Exalted, has bestowed exclusively upon human beings out of various beings. For this reason, Islam attaches significant importance to it and it deals ...
  • How should one, who has masturbated, repent? What are the ways through which one can make up for the physical and spiritual harms of masturbation?
    53807 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/08/10
    Sins are like an ill-smelling putrid bog. The deeper a person goes into it the less he feels its disgusting smell because his smelling taste ceases to function properly. However, a person's firm decision to discontinue lusting is by itself a victory.Masturbation has been considered to be one of ...

Popular