Advanced search
Visit
12259
Last Updated: 2010/09/05
Summary of question
Does the verse "فما استمتعتم به منهّن فاتوهن اجورهنّ فریضة" imply temporary marriage?
question
Does the verse "فما استمتعتم به منهّن فاتوهن اجورهنّ فریضة" imply temporary marriage? Why didn’t Allah demand the prophet to do so when mentioning the verse of Surah Nisa by using an amr verb?
Concise answer

What is meant by istimta in the verse "فما استمتعتم به منهّن فاتوهن اجورهنّ فریضة"; (For the enjoyment you have had from them thereby, give them their dowries, by way of settlement) , is intimacy and taking pleasure, so the verse is saying: Whenever you have taken pleasure in women provide them with their mahr (dowry).

The Shiite and also a group of scholars from the Sunni school of thought maintain: The verse implies the religious ritual of temporary marriage.

Muslim Ibn-Hajjaj has narrated in a sahih (auhtentic) hadith that Ata said: Jabir Ibn-Abdullah had recently arrived from Hajj and we went to visit him.

The people asked him about several issues one of which was mut’ah (fixed-term marriage). He replied: “Yes, we practiced mut’ah in the time of the Prophet, Abu Bakr and Umar.”

Thus we can understand why the great figures of the Sahabah (Companions of the Prophet) and the Tabe’in (Followers; Muslims born after the Prophet, but contemporaries of the Sahabah), a large amount of Sunni mufassirs (interpreters of the Quran) and all Shiite mufassirs have understood mut’ah from this verse.

The verse is seeking to mention those women who are legitimate to marry, instead of demanding to partake in the ritual of temporary or permanent marriage. Essentially, marriage, temporary or permanent, isn’t wajib per se, but rather it is mustahabb (recommended)[i] hence there is no reason for the amr  (imperative) form of the verb regarding this topic. So regarding the second part of the question the answer is that the primary implication of an amr (imperative) form of a verb in Fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence) is wujub (obligation) but no one has claimed temporary marriage to be wajib (obligatory).



[i] Fazel Lankarani, Mohammad, Tafsil Al-Shariah fi Sharh Tahrir Al-Wasilah, chapter of nikah, pg. 7.

Detailed Answer

Philologists state that the term istimta’ means intimacy and taking pleasure, so the verse is saying: Whenever you have taken pleasure in women provide them with their mahr (dowry).

Ibn Abbas, Sada, Ibn Sa’id and a group of the Tabe’in (Followers; Muslims born after the Prophet, but contemporaries of the Sahabah (Companions of the Prophet)) and The Followers of the Ahlul Bayt maintain: What is meant is temporary marriage.

This issue is pretty clear and evident, for although the term “istimta” and “tamatu’” literally mean taking pleasure and benefit, and in shar’i terms, this is confined to this type of contract , especially when it is combined with women (for example when it is said taking pleasure in women).

Therefore the meaning of this verse would be: “Whenever you have performed temporary marriage with them, give them their dowries”.

It has been narrated by a group of the Sahabah (Companions) namely Ubayy bin Ka’b, Abdullah Ibn Abbas and Abdullah bin Masuud that they used to recite this same verse in a slightly different way: “فما استمتعتم به منهن الى اجل مسمّى فآتوهن اجورهن”; meaning that whenever you take pleasure in them for a fixed term, give them their dowries from which clearly temporary marriage can be understood. This is very explicit and direct in mut’ah and temporary marriage.

Hence we can understand why the great figures of the “Sahabah” and “Tabe’in”; such as Ibn Abbas, the great scholar and renowned interpreter of the Quran, Ibn Ka’ab, Jabir Ibn Abdullah, Amran Husein, Sa’id Ibn Jubair, Mujahid, Qutadah, Sada, a vast majority of Sunni Interpreters and every single Shiite interpreter have understood the subject of mut’ah (fixed-term marraige) from the aforesaid verse to the extent that Fakhr Razi, who is known for being a tough critic of Shia standpoints, after thoroughly studying and discussing the verse, states: “We don’t deny the fact that the verse pertains to temporary marriage, what we are saying is that the hukm [of mut’ah] has been revoked later after its revelation.”[1]

Now regarding the second part of your question as to why Allah didn’t demand his Prophet to perform temporary marriage and why the Prophet wasn’t addressed in the amr (imperative) form of the verb for istimta’, we must say:

The primary implication of the amr (imperative) form of a verb is wujub (obligation) and nobody has claimed temporary marriage to be wajib (obligatory).[2]

Accordingly, the verse is seeking to mention those women who are legitimate to marry, instead of demanding to partake in the ritual of temporary or permanent marriage itself. Essentially, marriage, temporary or permanent, isn’t wajib per se, but rather it is mustahabb (recommended),[3] hence there is no need for the amr (imperative) form of the verb regarding this topic. On the other hand ahkam (Islamic rulings) are for everyone, not exclusively the Prophet (S.A.W.). As a result, if a verse in the Quran is pronouncing a taklif (religious duty) it will apply to everyone and they must to abide by it, even if the verse is only addressing the prophet.



[1] Makarem Shirazi, Naser, Tafsir Nemouneh, vol. 3, pg. 336.

[2] It should be noted that in the case of many wajib rulings we have that everyone agree on, their respective verses or hadiths don’t employ imperative verbs; for example, the obligation of fast; Allah (swt) says: “O you who have faith! Prescribed for you is fasting as it was prescribed for those who were before you, so that you may be God wary” (Baqarah:183), or the obligation of performing Hajj; Allah says: “In it are manifest signs [and] Abraham's Station, and whoever enters it shall be secure. And it is the duty of mankind toward Allah to make pilgrimage to the House for those who can afford the journey to it and should anyone renege [on his obligation], Allah is indeed without need of the creatures.” (Ale Imran:97).

[3] Fazel Lankarani, Mohammad, Tafsil Al-Shariah fi Sharh Tahrir Al-Wasilah, chapter of nikah, pg. 7.

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Is lobster, clam, oyster and octopus halal?
    110783 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/02/18
    Eating lobster, clam, oyster and octopus is haram. According to religious resources regarding halal and haram meat, there are general rulings and numerous standards; for instance, a set of rulings has been given for land animals, sea creatures, birds and so on.The condition for halal meat sea ...
  • Is ‘Apprehension’ a quality that can be attributed to God?
    6722 Traditional 2012/04/17
    Taking into consideration the verse “لا تُدْرِكُهُ الْأَبْصارُ وَ هُوَ يُدْرِكُ الْأَبْصارَ وَ هُوَ اللَّطيفُ الْخَبيرُ”[1], Mudrik (being apprehensive) is one of God’s names.[2] In the Quran and traditions, this attribute (Mudrik)[3] has been mentioned explicitly, thus ...
  • Please explain the concept of infallibility. Is it possible for anyone besides the infallible imams (as) to be infallible?
    11727 Traditional 2009/06/22
    In a theological dictionary, one the possesses infallibility would be defined as an infallible. An infallible is one who, by the grace of God, is free from all forms of mistake and error, and does not commit even the smallest of sins. However, one who is infallible isn't ...
  • What are the ways through which one may get rid of lusts?
    8337 Practical 2011/08/04
    Sins are like an ill-smelling putrid bog. The deeper a person gets into it the less he feels its disgusting smell because his smelling taste ceases to function. However, a person's firm decision to discontinue this path is by itself a victory. One who has achieved victory ...
  • How do we return to nothingness?
    8112 Contextual study 2009/09/23
    This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer. ...
  • What is meant by the Makr of Allah that has been mentioned in the Quran?
    22017 Exegesis 2011/04/20
    “Makr” means to devise for good or evil and this is why it is described by the word “السَّیئ” (bad/evil) in the Quran.Allah’s Makr: The many verses that attribute “Makr” to Allah refer to his supreme direction and regulation of matters.  Since he is the ...
  • Is it permissible to open and close tap several times during Wudhu so as not to waste water?
    8929 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/09/22
    Office of Grand Ayatollah Khamenei (may Allah grant him long life): There is no problem in it. Generally speaking, there is no objection in opening and closing tap before washing the left hand completely. However, if one touches a wet thing (such as a wet ...
  • What is Nafaqah?
    13509 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/04/19
    ‘Nafaqah’ is a jurisprudential term used for women, kin (relatives) and property. It is predominantly used for women/wives and denotes the financial support that is obligatory upon men (when certain conditions are met) to provide for their spouses.[1] The Nafaqah usually covers the wife’s ...
  • Are there any guidelines in the Islamic sources about fashion and clothing?
    9366 Practical 2012/07/15
    Although Islam lays great emphasis on spiritual modesty of human beings (clothing of piety), the outward clothing is also a bounty which God, the Exalted, has bestowed exclusively upon human beings out of various beings. For this reason, Islam attaches significant importance to it and it deals ...
  • How should one, who has masturbated, repent? What are the ways through which one can make up for the physical and spiritual harms of masturbation?
    53807 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/08/10
    Sins are like an ill-smelling putrid bog. The deeper a person goes into it the less he feels its disgusting smell because his smelling taste ceases to function properly. However, a person's firm decision to discontinue lusting is by itself a victory.Masturbation has been considered to be one of ...

Popular