Advanced search
Visit
8724
Last Updated: 2009/12/17
Summary of question
Is infallibility based on predestination or free will?
question
It is narrated from a book by the late Mudhaffar, called ‘Aqaidul Imamiya’ that the Infallibles (a) did not (and do not) have the capability of sinning or making mistakes. I have heard from another scholar that the Infallibles (a) did (and do) have the capability of sinning but they would choose not to from their own free will. Why does Mudhaffar say that they do not have any free will and are forced not to sin? Is Mudahaffar considered a famous scholar and are his books authentic? Is it possible that in the English translation of the book which I read a mistake was made?
Concise answer

This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer.

Detailed Answer

The infallibility of the Prophets (a) and ‘Aimmah’ (a) is considered one of the important beliefs of the Shia. For a deeper discussion of this matter you can refer to the questions: 1737 (site: 1733) , 1739 (site: 1734), and 3026 (site: ) in this same website.  In reference to the question which you asked it has to be said that in the original Arabic text of ‘Aqaidul Imamiya’, written by Allamah Muhamad Reza Mudhaffar who is counted as one of the famous and great Shia scholars, we did not find any reference to such a statement which said that the infallibles are forced not to sin and that they have no choice in the matter. In fact, in certain traditions, the opposite has been mentioned that they do have free will. Even more explicitly we have the words [1] (of Allamah Mudhaffar) who said in regards to the infallibility of the ‘Aimmah’: ومن الامور التی یجب التنبیه علیها ایضاً هو ان المعصوم(ع) لیس مجبوراً علی فعل الطاعات و ترک المعاصی، و انما فعل و ترک باختیاره؛ لانّ العصمة ملکة و بصیرة فی الامور؛ اذ انه ینفر من المعاصی و یبتعد عنها، و یتشوّق الی الطاعة فیعملها، و کل ذلک بتوفیق من الله عز و جل [2] which means: “One matter which is important to mention is that the Infallibles (a) are not forced to obey God and not commit sins; they act based on their own free will. This is because infallibility is a type of insight and inner vision into matters and the person who is infallible has an aversion towards sinning and stays far away from them. Furthermore, they have an eagerness towards obeying God and act based on these principles. While these things are not forcing them into predestination, they are still a great favor and grace from God.

Hence, the words of the late Mudhaffar clearly point to the free will of the infallibles and not to any sort of predestination. It is possible that in the English translation of the text there was a misprint or mistake. It is also possible that in the reading of the text a misunderstanding occurred.



[1] The late Mudhaffar has mentioned this matter in the second point in discussion on the infallibility of the prophets.

[2] Mudhaffar, Muhammad Ridha, Aqa’idul-Imamah, pg. 77.

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

Popular