Advanced search
Visit
19999
Last Updated: 2011/01/26
Summary of question
Is there any reason for the permissibility of chest beating and self-hitting of some Muslims that is done in Muharram and other times?
question
Please explain to me why some Muslims beat their chest and hit themselves during Muharram? Isn't it haram to hit or hurt yourself? Do we have any example for the Prophet doing this? Did any Imams hit themselves because of the martyrdom of a person?
Concise answer

Mourning for Imam Husein (as) is one of the highest forms of worship, and doing anything for him that is considered a form of mourning in culture and society is permissible, unless it really brings about a considerable amount of harm to the body, or is a means of the undermining of the Shia and the Ahlul-Bayt’s school of thought; chest beating is none of the two, so it is permissible. Because of none of the above applying to it, and since it is a form of lament and mourning for that great imam (as), it is mustahabb.

Detailed Answer

Mourning for Imam Husein (as) is one of the highest forms of worship, and doing anything for him that is considered a form of mourning in culture and society is permissible, unless it really brings about a considerable amount of harm to the body, or is a means of the undermining of the Shia and the Ahlul-Bayt’s school of thought; chest beating is none of the two, so it is permissible. Because of none of the above applying to it, and since it is a form of lament and mourning for that great imam (as), it is mustahabb. [1]

For further information on the rulings pertaining to mourning for Imam Husein (as), refer to: How mourning for Imam Husein began, Question 3914 (website: 4197), The outcomes of mourning for Imam Husein, Question 2303 (website: 2518), The permissibility of mourning for Imam Husein and the hadiths in this regard, Questio n 7183 (website: 7277), Mourning for Imam Husein; a means of liveliness of society, Question 348 (website: 352) on this website.

In addition to the responses that can be found on this website, there are also hadiths on beating on one’s head and chest for Imam Husein, namely: “The narrator says: When Imam Kadhim (as) was apprehended, he told his son Imam Ridha (as) to sleep at the entrance door of his home as long as he (Imam Kadhim) is alive until news of his father comes.

He says: We would prepare the sleeping place of Imam Ridha (as) every night and he would sleep there every night after dinner and would return to his own home in the morning. Four years passed like this until one night, when we were preparing his sleeping place, he didn’t come like every other night and this matter worried us and those in the home. The next night the imam came to the home and went to his father’s family and summoned Umm Ahmad and told her: Bring the trust my father had entrusted you with. Upon hearing this, Umm Ahmad screamed and slapped her face and tore her collar saying: By Allah my master (Imam Kadhim) has passed away! Imam Ridha (as) said to her: Don’t say anything in this regard and don’t disclose it to anyone, until the news reaches the governor…”. [2]

Although in this hadith, the person screaming and beating herself isn't the imam (as), but the point here is that all of it was done in the imam’s (as) presence and the imam didn’t say anything to prevent it. Such silence is confirmation [3] by the imam (as) and is binding for others.

There are other hadiths that indicate that the household of the prophet (pbuh) would rend their collars in tragedies. This matter has been narrated about Imam Askari [4] and also Lady Zaynab [5] .



[1] This is Ayatullah Mahdi Hadavi Tehrani’s response to the inquiry. Grand Ayatullah Safi Golpaygani’s response in this regard is: If it doesn’t cause considerable harm to the body, it is permissible per se.

[2] Kuleini, Muhammad bin Yaqub, Kafi, vol. 1, pp. 381 and 382, Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyyah, Tehran, 1365.

[3] Tradition is comprised of three elements: the action, saying and confirmation of an infallible.

[4] Majlisi, Muhammad Baqir, Bihar al-Anwar, vol. 50, pg. 191, Al-Wafa’ Institute, Lebanon, 1404 (AH); Kashi, Muhammad bin Umar, Rijal Kashi, pg. 480, Daneshgah Mashad Publications, 1348.

[5] Seyed Ali bin Musa bin Tawus, Al-Luhuf, pp. 178 and 179, Jahan Publications, Tehran, 1348.

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • What is the veracity of the supplication “Allahumma kun li-waliyyik al-Hujjatibnil Hasan… and how do we know that it is authentic?
    12403 Contextual study 2017/05/22
    This holy supplication has been reported with some variation in different Shia sources including the book of Al-Kafi. It is good to recite this dua for the wellbeing of Imam of Time, may Allah hasten his reappearance. Generally speaking, the different parts of this dua indicate the ...
  • Is it true that every human being has a twin or an associate?
    11775 Contextual study 2015/06/09
    As for whether human beings have twins or not, there are a few narrations. It has been reported that God, the Exalted, told Iblis: I will not give Adam a child except that I will give the like of it to you. Every human being has a ...
  • Was the Prophet of Islam (S) a prophet at birth?
    7536 وحی، نبوت و عصمت 2018/10/22
    The prophethood of the Prophet of Islam (S) can be considered as having two aspects: 1. The first aspect of prophethood is tantamount to prophetic mission and the beginning of a procedure which involved promulgation and propagation of the religion as well as the establishment of the ...
  • Is it possible to see God? If so, then how?
    9594 Traditional 2010/04/08
    According to both Islamic sources and the intellect, God cannot be seen by the physical eye neither in this life nor in the next. However He can be seen through the eyes of the heart. Up to each given individual’s capacity, after purifying their souls, and engaging in prayers and ...
  • What is the Islamic law about pictures ascribed to the Imams (a.s.)?
    9563 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/10/29
    What follows are answers given to the above question by the religious authorities (grand jurists):Grand Ayatollah Khamenei (may Allah grant him long life): As per the Islamic law, there is no problem in it by itself provided that it is ...
  • What is the Maqam Ibrahim? What is its purpose?
    41598 Traditional 2010/02/14
    One of the clear signs in Makkah (as a verse in the Quran tells us) is the Maqam Ibrahim where Prophet Ibrahim stood.Regarding the meaning and interpretation of “Maqam Ibrahim”, some believe that it is equal to all of Hajj. Others ...
  • Are the punishments for some sins harsher and greater by many folds than the punishments for some other sins?
    7273 Theoretical 2012/01/04
    It is inferred from the Holy Qur'an and traditions of the Ahlul-Bayt (a.s.) that there are different degrees of torments in hell, proportioned to the different degrees of sins on earth. The Quran considers associating partners with God (shirk) as the greatest sin. Also, God warns to punish the sinners ...
  • Why does the verdict of a marja become invalid after his death?
    8184 Philosophy of Religion and Law 2007/04/08
    It must be known that ijtihad has different elements: some are firm (ex. Quran, prophetic traditions, intellect…) and others are changeable (ex. Subjects and their conditions, knowledge and the understanding of the marja himself). A mujtahid must always be aware of the changeable elements. Hence, it ...
  • What is Islam’s ruling on listening to music?
    14879 Laws and Jurisprudence 2010/11/21
    Music is essentially sound, and watching it (without listening) has no ruling; the only ruling there is, has to do with producing and the sale of instruments, teaching and learning, playing, and listening to it. Most scholars consider listening to and producing lahwi music to be haram and ...
  • How come although all of us gave an oath in the Alame-Arwah, there are still people who have religions other than Islam?
    30866 Traditional 2009/03/14
    In our religious texts and scriptures, a realm or world by the name of Dharr has been spoken of. There are differences between the scholars regarding what this realm exactly is. Nevertheless, the viewpoint which seems to be the best of all is the one that says Allah ...

Popular