Advanced search
Visit
7688
Last Updated: 2007/02/14
Summary of question
Taking into consideration the uniformity of the resources used by Mujtahids, why is there sometimes discrepancy in their opinions?
question
Taking into consideration the fact that the resources used by Mujtahids are all the same, then why do their opinions sometimes differ on the same issues?
Concise answer

Having an identical opinion and fatwa amongst Mujtahids is dependent upon several things:

 

  1. Usage of identical Ijtihad resources

  2. Uniformity in prerequisite resources which Ijtihad is contingent upon

  3. Uniformity in comprehension from these Ijtihad resources

  4. Uniformity in verification and judgment of applicability

Even though in Shia fiqh, the resources amongst Mujtahids are evident, specific and the same; nevertheless the basis of Mujtahids may differ in the issues of the required sciences for Ijtihad. Just as their aptitude, degree of knowledge and resourcefulness may not be the same; neither will the comprehension of their resources. This is the reason for some of the discrepancies of fatwas. There may also be discrepancies in distinguishing and determining certain subjects as that is the job of an expert or specialist [in the regarding field], which would in turn result in a difference of fatwas.

Even with taking into consideration these facts, still yet the amount of discrepancies and differences in fatwas are a great deal less than the instances of equivalence and uniformity in the fatwas of Mujtahids.

Detailed Answer

The word Ijtihad (which comes from the root word jahada[1]) means to tolerate difficulties. It also means strength and ability (from the root word johada[2]). The term used in Islamic legal ruling means; using the utmost scholarly effort in order to derive and attain a legal [Islamic] ruling from resources and their evidence.

Therefore, having an identical opinion and fatwa amongst Mujtahids is contingent upon several things:

 

  1. Usage of identical Ijtihad resources

  2. Uniformity in prerequisite resources which Ijtihad is contingent upon

  3. Uniformity in comprehension from these Ijtihad resources

  4. Uniformity in [accurate] verification and judgment of applicability

Even though in Shia fiqh the resources for Ijtihad (Quran, Sunnah and Reasoning) are the same amongst Mujtahids, and they all recognize these resources as being creditable; nevertheless, in order to comprehend, make use and derive from these resources other information is necessary, such as; Arabic Syntax, knowledge of customary practices during the time of the Masooms (P.B.U.T.), Logic, principals of Islamic jurisprudence, knowledge of the identity and reliability of hadith transmitters[3], solid comprehension and awareness of Quran and Hadith, etc.[4] Every Faqih (legal scholar), in addition to having sufficient knowledge in these fields, must also have a basis in all of the issues relating to these fields so that he can be able to uses these sciences to better understand the resources of Ijtihad. For example, in using a hadith or narration it is possible that one Mujtahid may not recognize the authenticity of a particular hadith based on the accepted values in the science of Rijal and therefore not use that as a basis for certification and attaining an Islamic legal ruling; yet that may be the only hadith available on that particular issue other than that particular hadith. As a result this Faqih can not give a ruling on that issue, while at the same time other legal scholars may recognize that same hadith as being authentic and use it as grounds for attaining an Islamic legal ruling. The analyzing ability and strength is not the same for all Mujtahids, which is why it is possible for Mujtahids to have a different understanding of a hadith or Quranic verse. Also, it is possible for a Mujtahids to recognize a specific thing as being specific to a particular instance or applicability, while another Mujtahids may not share the same view.

Every single one of these scenarios can be the cause of discrepancies between the fatwas of Mujtahids, yet even so, having taken all of this into consideration, the amount of discrepancies and differences in fatwas are not many and are mostly in the details. However in the majority of issues (with respect to the close to 3000 issue which are in the Towzi Ul-Masa'el[5]of Mujtahids) Mujtahids are uniform in fatwa and opinion.



[1]Al-Nahayah: Vol.1, Pg.319

[2]Al-Nahayah: Vol.1, Pg.319

[3]Known as the science of “Rijal”

[4]See: The Theological essentials of Ijtihad: By Dr. Hadavi Tehrani, Pg.19 & 20

[5]Catechism or book compiled with a collection of issues of which a Mujtahid has given a fatwa or legal ruling on.

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

Popular